1959 Annie Get Your Gun Max Muller
1960 Showboat Max Muller
1960 Oklahoma Max Muller
1961 Wizard of Oz Max Muller
1961 Pagliacci Max Muller
1961 Where’s Charlie Max Muller
1962 Girl Crazy Phil Harris
1962 Red Mill Phil Harris
1963 South Pacific H. Jay Thompson
1963 Pirates of Penzance H. Jay Thompson
1963 Brigadoon H. Jay Thompson
1964 The King and I H. Jay Thompson
1964 Guys and Dolls H. Jay Thompson
1965 Carnival Prince Elmquist
1965 Wildcat Prince Elmquist
1966 110 in the Shade Prince Elmquist
1966 Hit the Deck Prince Elmquist
1967 Calamity Jane Prince Elmquist
1967 Naughty Marietta Prince Elmquist
1968 None  
1969 Carousel Elmer Copley
1970 The Bells Are Ringing Carlton Woods
1971 Kiss Me Kate Carlton Woods
1972 Most Happy Fella Elmer Copley
1973 Fiddler on the Roof Elmer Copley
1974 Guys and Dolls Elmer Copley
1975 The King and I Elmer Copley
1976 The Unsinkable Molly Brown Elmer Copley
1977 Bye, Bye Birdie Julie Goering
1978 Hello Dolly Carlene Berg
1979 Music Man Carlene Berg
1980 Fiddler on the Roof Carlene Berg
1981   Carlene Berg
1982 South Pacific Carlene Berg
1983 Good Man, Charlie Brown Carlene Berg
1984 Anything Goes Carlene Berg
1985 Annie! Carlene Berg
1986 Give My Regards to Broadway Carlene Berg
1987 My One and Only Carlene Berg
1988 Kiss Me Kate Michael J. Lange
1989 Little Red Riding Hood Carlene Berg
1989 Three Penny Opera Michael J. Lange
1990 Magical Pied Piper Linda Anderson
1990 Annie Get Your Gun Prince Elmquist
1991 Robin Hood Linda Anderson
1991 Music Man  
1992 Krazy Kamp Linda Anderson
1992 The Unsinkable Molly Brown Linda Anderson
1993 None  
1994 1940’s Radio Hour Diane Davies
1994 Wizard of Oz Diane Davies
1994 The Importance of Being Earnest Vicki Bakken
1995 Brigadoon Sherrilyn Parker
1995 American Heritage Mindy Wilson
1996 Sound of Music Sherrilyn Parker
1996 Tales of Hans Christian Anderson Anna Prockish
1997 Carousel Rebecca Copley Johnson
1998 Cinderella S. Jeff Dary
1999 Hello Dolly Norm Schroder
2000 Give My Regards to Broadway Michael J. Lange
2001 Fiddler on the Roof Linda Anderson
2002 Oklahoma! Rebecca Copley Johnson
2003 Most Happy Fella Rebecca Copley Johnson
2004 Camelot Cody Whetstone
2005 Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Lisa Christopher
2006 South Pacific Lisa Christopher
2007 Damn Yankees Cody Whetstone
2008 State Fair Allison Moore
2009 Annie Get Your Gun J.D. Bowman
2010 Good Man Charlie Brown Gary Demuth
2011 Willy Wonka Molly Johnson
2012 Pirates of Penzance Gary Demuth
2013 Guys and Dolls Lisa Christopher
2014 Oliver Gary Demuth
2015 Wizard of Oz Eric Lundstrom
2016 Joseph & The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Lisa Christopher
2017 Beauty and the Beast Eric Lundstrom
2018 Annie Eric Johnson
2019 Sondheim on Sondheim Eric Lundstrom
2019 Into the Woods Eric Lundstrom
2020 Not Performed due to COVID-19 Pandemic  
2021 Mamma Mia! Gary Demuth
2022 Shrek The Musical Barbara Hilt